Insoryx
Auto Services

How Much Does Auto Repair Shop Insurance Cost?

Your shop holds tens of thousands of dollars of other people's cars every night — and general liability won't pay when one is damaged. Here's what mechanics pay, and the garagekeepers coverage most shops underbuy.

IXInsoryx ResearchUpdated Nov 20269 min read
How Much Does Auto Repair Shop Insurance Cost?
Quick answer

Auto repair shops pay a median of about $54 a month ($652 a year) for general liability, $149 a month ($1,787 a year) for a business owner's policy and $150 a month for workers' comp, according to Insureon. Garagekeepers coverage — which protects customers' cars in your care — is priced separately based on how many vehicles and how much value you hold. Most small shops spend $4,000–$8,000 a year in total.

Key takeaways
  • General liability: about $54/month median for repair shops.
  • BOP about $149/month; workers' comp about $150/month.
  • General liability doesn't cover customers' cars — garagekeepers does.
  • Direct primary garagekeepers costs more but pays regardless of fault.

How much is auto repair shop insurance?

$54/mo
General liability
$149/mo
Business owner's policy
$150/mo
Workers' comp
PolicyMonthlyAnnual
General liability$54$652
Commercial package policy$101$1,208
Commercial auto$103$1,227
Business owner's policy$149$1,787
Workers' compensation$150$1,796
GaragekeepersQuoted by vehicle count & value—

Insureon medians for auto repair and mechanic businesses. Body shops, transmission specialists and shops that store many vehicles overnight pay more, mainly through garagekeepers and property limits.

Garage liability vs. garagekeepers: what's the difference?

Garage liabilityGaragekeepers
CoversInjuries and damage to others caused by your operations or repairsCustomers' vehicles in your care, custody or control
ExampleA customer slips in the bay; a bad brake job causes a crashA car is stolen from your lot, damaged in a fire or dented on a test drive
Do you need it?Yes — the core liability policy for garagesYes, if you ever hold customer cars
The 'care, custody or control' gap
General liability excludes property in your care, custody or control. Without garagekeepers, a fire that damages ten customer cars can be uninsured.
Find your coverage gaps

Our risk assessment guide walks through the losses that can close a shop — and which policy covers each.

Read the guide

Which garagekeepers option should you buy?

  1. Legal liability — pays only if you're legally at fault. Cheapest, but slow and contentious.
  2. Direct excess — pays regardless of fault, after the customer's own auto insurance.
  3. Direct primary — pays regardless of fault, first. Most expensive, best for customer relationships.

Set your limit per location at the highest total value of customer cars you hold on a busy day, not your average.

How to lower auto repair shop insurance

  • Lock keys in a key box and light and camera the lot
  • Bring cars inside overnight where possible
  • Limit test drives to certified staff with clean MVRs
  • Keep shop floors and lifts on a documented safety schedule
  • Bundle garage liability, garagekeepers and property
  • Choose higher deductibles on garagekeepers comprehensive
Free · 45 seconds

Get auto repair shop quotes

A licensed broker compares garage liability, garagekeepers and property for your shop.

🔒 Shared with one broker only. Never sold to lists.

Frequently asked questions

Most small shops pay $4,000–$8,000 a year in total. Insureon's medians are $54/month for GL, $149/month for a BOP and $150/month for workers' comp.

Coverage for customers' vehicles while they're in your care, custody or control — parked, being repaired or on a test drive.

No. General liability excludes property in your care, custody or control. You need garagekeepers.

Yes. Garage liability is the standard liability policy for auto service businesses, covering injuries and damage caused by your operations and completed work.

If you ever take a customer's car into your possession, yes. Mobile mechanics who only work on site may need less.