Will you owe at your workers' comp audit?
Find out before the auditor does: will you owe money or get a refund?
Quick answer
Your workers' comp premium is a deposit based on estimated payroll. At the end of the policy an auditor recalculates it from actual payroll by class code. Payroll growth, payments to subcontractors who can't show a certificate of insurance, and misclassified employees create bills. Excluding the premium portion of overtime (allowed in most NCCI states) creates credits.
- Audit timing
- Within ~60–90 days of policy expiration
- Uninsured sub payments
- Usually added to your payroll
- Overtime premium portion
- Excludable in most NCCI states
- Owner/officer payroll
- Fixed min/max by state
1Payroll by class code
2What auditors look for
Estimated audit bill
$19,760
Due after the audit — usually within 30 days.
Audited premium
$52,874
vs. $33,114 paid up front
What moved your bill
- Payroll growth+$8,810
- Uninsured subcontractors+$12,600
- Overtime exclusion−$1,650
$12,600 of this bill is uninsured subcontractors.
Get a valid certificate from each sub covering the dates they worked and most of this disappears. Send them to the auditor even after the audit — many carriers accept corrections.Get your line-by-line audit worksheet + checklist
Free. Unlocks every Insoryx calculator.
How to use the workers' comp audit estimator
- 1
Enter estimated and actual payroll
Use the payroll on your policy declarations and what you actually paid, for each class code.
- 2
Add uninsured subcontractors
Total what you paid subs who didn't give you a valid workers' comp certificate. Auditors usually treat it as your payroll.
- 3
Add the overtime premium
Only the extra half of time-and-a-half is usually excludable — enter that portion, not total overtime.
- 4
See the bill or refund
We show the audited premium, what drove the difference, and the checklist that keeps the audit clean.
Key numbers
| Audit timing | Within ~60–90 days of policy expiration |
|---|---|
| Uninsured sub payments | Usually added to your payroll |
| Overtime premium portion | Excludable in most NCCI states |
| Owner/officer payroll | Fixed min/max by state |
Questions people ask
Straight answers. Your broker or carrier has the final word on your policy.
Why do I owe money after a workers' comp audit?
Your initial premium was based on estimated payroll. If actual payroll was higher, employees were in a more expensive class code, or you paid subcontractors who couldn't prove they had their own coverage, the audited premium goes up and you're billed the difference.
Are subcontractors included in a workers' comp audit?
Payments to subcontractors who carried their own workers' comp (with a valid certificate covering the work dates) are generally excluded. Payments to uninsured subs are usually treated as your payroll and charged at the sub's class rate.
Is overtime included in workers' comp payroll?
In most NCCI states only the straight-time portion counts. The premium portion — the extra half of time-and-a-half — can be excluded if your payroll records show it separately.
Can I dispute a workers' comp audit?
Yes. Ask for the auditor's worksheet, check class codes, overtime and subcontractor treatment, and send missing certificates. Most carriers accept corrections within a set period, and every state has a formal dispute process.
How do I avoid a big audit bill?
Update your payroll estimate mid-year if it changes, collect a certificate from every sub before they start work, keep overtime separated in payroll, and track employees' hours by class code.
Methodology
Estimates use published rating methods and typical market ranges by trade and state, reviewed November 2026. They are educational, not a quote or your official rating — actual premiums depend on underwriting, carrier and loss history.More free tools
Keep going
Uninsured Subcontractor Cost Calculator
What subs without a certificate of insurance will add to your GL and workers' comp audit.
Open toolEMR Calculator
Estimate your experience mod and see what one injury really costs over three years.
Open toolContract Insurance Cost Calculator
What a contract's insurance requirements add to your bid, line by line.
Open tool