How much landlord insurance do you need — and what will it cost?
Landlord insurance cost per unit, how much coverage you need, and the coinsurance trap.
Quick answer
Landlord (dwelling fire) insurance typically costs about 15–25% more than a homeowners policy on the same building. Insure the building for its full replacement cost — not market value — add 12 months of loss of rents and at least $1M of liability. Insuring below 80% of replacement cost can trigger a coinsurance penalty that cuts every claim.
- Building coverage
- Full replacement cost
- Loss of rents
- 12 months of rent
- Liability
- $1M per occurrence (+ umbrella)
- Coinsurance minimum
- Usually 80% of replacement cost
1The property
2Your policy & risks
Estimated premium
$2,089–$3,108
per year
Per unit, per month
$212
Insure the building for
$342K
≈ $190/sq ft to rebuild
- Building (replacement cost)$2,185
- Liability$310
- Loss of rents (12 mo)$53
You may be underinsured by $53,600.
Below 80% of replacement cost, a coinsurance clause cuts every claim. On a $100,000 loss you could pay about $19,591 yourself on top of the deductible.Get your coverage checklist + coinsurance math
Free. Unlocks every Insoryx calculator.
How to use the rental property insurance calculator
- 1
Describe the property
Type, units, square footage, year built and state.
- 2
Add rents and risk factors
Monthly rent per unit, short-term rental use, coastal or wildfire exposure.
- 3
Enter your current coverage
We check it against replacement cost and the 80% coinsurance rule.
- 4
See cost and coverage targets
Annual premium range, cost per unit per month, and the limits to ask for.
Key numbers
| Building coverage | Full replacement cost |
|---|---|
| Loss of rents | 12 months of rent |
| Liability | $1M per occurrence (+ umbrella) |
| Coinsurance minimum | Usually 80% of replacement cost |
| Best form for most landlords | DP-3 (open perils) |
Questions people ask
Straight answers. Your broker or carrier has the final word on your policy.
How much does landlord insurance cost?
For a single-family rental it's often $1,200–$3,500 a year, but storm-exposed states like Florida, Louisiana, Oklahoma and Texas run much higher. Cost depends on replacement cost, age, location, deductible and use.
How much coverage do I need on a rental property?
Insure the building for full replacement cost (what it costs to rebuild, not what it would sell for), carry loss of rents equal to about 12 months of rent, and at least $1M of liability.
What is the coinsurance penalty?
If your building limit is below the required percentage of replacement cost (often 80%), the insurer reduces each claim payment in proportion to your shortfall — even on small claims.
What's the difference between DP-1, DP-2 and DP-3?
DP-1 covers named perils at actual cash value; DP-2 adds more named perils and usually replacement cost; DP-3 covers all perils not excluded, at replacement cost, and is what most landlords should buy.
Does landlord insurance cover short-term rentals?
Often not by default. Airbnb-style use usually needs a short-term rental policy or endorsement, which costs more.
Methodology
Estimates use published rating methods and typical market ranges by trade and state, reviewed November 2026. They are educational, not a quote or your official rating — actual premiums depend on underwriting, carrier and loss history.More free tools
Keep going
Business Umbrella Calculator
How much commercial umbrella you actually need — and what each $1M costs.
Open toolContract Insurance Cost Calculator
What a contract's insurance requirements add to your bid, line by line.
Open toolEMR Calculator
Estimate your experience mod and see what one injury really costs over three years.
Open tool