The hidden bill for subs without a COI.
What subs without a certificate of insurance will add to your GL and workers' comp audit.
Quick answer
When you pay a subcontractor who can't show a valid certificate of insurance, your carrier usually treats that money as your own exposure at audit. Workers' comp is charged on the labor portion (sometimes the full payment) at the sub's class rate, and general liability charges uninsured subcontract cost at rates often 5–20 times higher than for insured subs.
- Typical WC treatment
- Labor portion charged as your payroll
- No labor breakdown
- Full payment may be charged
- GL rate on uninsured subs
- Often 5–20× the insured-sub rate
- Fix
- Collect a valid COI before work starts
1The subcontractors
Surprise audit charge
$23,010
Added to your GL + workers' comp at audit
If every sub sent a COI
$375
You'd keep ≈ $22,635
- Workers' comp charge$15,750
- General liability charge$7,260
- GL with valid COIs$375
Stop chasing certificates by hand. Insoryx Comply's AI agents collect and check every sub's COI and flag expirations before your auditor does.
Try it free for 7 daysNo labor breakdown on invoices?
Some auditors charge 100% of the payment — that would make the workers' comp charge $31,500. Ask subs to itemize labor and materials.See the auditor's math + how to reverse the charge
Free. Unlocks every Insoryx calculator.
How to use the uninsured subcontractor cost calculator
- 1
Pick the sub's trade and your state
The sub's class code sets the workers' comp rate the auditor will apply.
- 2
Enter what you paid without certificates
Separate payments to subs with no workers' comp proof from those with no general liability proof.
- 3
Set the labor share
If invoices don't split labor from materials, many auditors charge the full amount. A common allowance is 33–90% labor depending on trade.
- 4
See the audit charge
We estimate the GL and WC charges and compare them with what they'd be if every sub had sent a certificate.
Key numbers
| Typical WC treatment | Labor portion charged as your payroll |
|---|---|
| No labor breakdown | Full payment may be charged |
| GL rate on uninsured subs | Often 5–20× the insured-sub rate |
| Fix | Collect a valid COI before work starts |
Questions people ask
Straight answers. Your broker or carrier has the final word on your policy.
Why does my insurance charge for uninsured subcontractors?
If a sub has no coverage, an injury to their worker or damage they cause can come back to your policy. Your carrier prices that risk at audit by adding the sub's payments to your exposure base.
What counts as a valid certificate of insurance at audit?
A certificate naming the subcontractor as the insured, showing the right coverage (workers' comp and/or GL), with policy dates covering the whole time they worked for you. Expired or missing certificates are usually treated as uninsured.
Does a 1099 subcontractor need workers' comp?
It depends on the state and whether they have employees, but from your carrier's point of view an uninsured 1099 sub is usually charged as your payroll unless you have a valid certificate or a state-accepted exemption.
How do I avoid uninsured subcontractor charges?
Require a certificate before work starts, check that it covers the right dates and limits, track renewals, and keep copies ready for the auditor. Tools like Insoryx Comply automate this.
Can I get the charge removed after the audit?
Often, yes — if you can produce a certificate that was valid during the work dates. Send it to the auditor or carrier quickly; most allow corrections within a set window.
Methodology
Estimates use published rating methods and typical market ranges by trade and state, reviewed November 2026. They are educational, not a quote or your official rating — actual premiums depend on underwriting, carrier and loss history.More free tools
Keep going
Workers' Comp Audit Estimator
Find out before the auditor does: will you owe money or get a refund?
Open toolContract Insurance Cost Calculator
What a contract's insurance requirements add to your bid, line by line.
Open toolEMR Calculator
Estimate your experience mod and see what one injury really costs over three years.
Open tool